McNeil’s bat was strong in 2025 with a .746 OPS, and his defense at second was elite among Mets, offering positional flexibility across the outfield. As a potential trade candidate, his value hinges on balancing offense with defensive depth and roster flexibility.

B- to B range; solid 122 games and center-field contributions, but not the offensive peak some expected. Defense was acceptable, offense steady, but not the driver of the season’s success.

McNeil surfaces as part of the roster-construction conversation around whether to preserve offense or pivot to defense. His value as a contact hitter and defender makes him a potential trade candidate in a defense-first reshaping, though his versatility keeps him in the mix.

<p>McNeil appears in discussions about the core’s flexibility and potential moves, reflecting how a broader reshaping of the roster could impact his role and fantasy value.</p>

<p>McNeil’s versatility and staple role on the Mets’ roster supported multi-category contributions amid a powerful but imperfect lineup.</p><p>His continued value hinges on playing time, positional flexibility, and lineup protection around him in 2026.</p>